Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
19 Years
experience
Custom Cakes & Handcrafted Desserts in Buffalo, NY
At Fairy Cakes Bakeshop, we take pride in crafting high-quality baked goods from scratch using fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. Established in 2007 as a catering business, we opened our Buffalo, NY storefront in 2011 and have since become a beloved local destination for custom cakes, cookies, and dessert tables. Our team of skilled bakers and decorators brings creativity and expertise to every order, whether it's a classic treat or a fully customized dessert display. Featured on the Cooking Channel's Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats, we combine tradition with innovation to deliver memorable experiences.

In 2024, founder Kelly Audette and partner Maureen Torpey passed the business to longtime employee Nicolle, ensuring continuity of our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. We specialize in creating desserts that reflect personal tastes and event themes while maintaining a family-friendly atmosphere. From single servings to large-scale events, our focus remains on using premium ingredients and delivering exceptional service to meet diverse customer needs.
Services
Custom Cakes Cupcakes Dessert Tables Cookie Decorating Baking Workshops Seasonal Treats Allergy-Friendly Options Wedding Desserts Corporate Events Take-and-Bake Items
Details
  • Year established: 2007
Highlights and features
  • We have over 17 years of experience in scratch-made baking
  • Our team creates custom designs for weddings and special events
  • Featured on Cooking Channel's Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats
  • Offer monthly cookie decorating workshops for all skill levels
  • Provide allergy-friendly dessert options for events
Services
Custom Cakes
We create custom-designed cakes for weddings and special events using fresh ingredients and classic recipes. Our team works closely with clients to develop unique flavor combinations and decorative elements that match event themes. Available in multiple sizes from single-tier to elaborate multi-tier displays.
Dessert Tables
Full-service dessert table arrangements featuring a variety of mini desserts including cupcakes, cake pops, and seasonal specialties. We offer pre-designed packages and fully customizable options with delivery and setup available for Buffalo area events.
Cupcakes
Hand-decorated cupcakes made from scratch in classic and seasonal flavors. Available individually or by the dozen with options for custom designs and themed decorations to match any occasion.
Cookie Decorating
Guided cookie decorating workshops held monthly at our Buffalo location. Participants learn professional techniques while creating themed designs using our signature buttercream and fondant decorations.
Seasonal Treats
Specialty desserts featuring seasonal flavors like pumpkin spice, apple cinnamon, and holiday-themed decorations. Available during specific times of year with both pre-designed and custom order options.
People
Kelly Audette
Founder
Founded Fairy Cakes in 2007, developing it from a catering business into a successful Buffalo storefront before passing it to new ownership in 2024.
Maureen Torpey
Former Partner
Business partner from 2011-2024 who helped expand the menu and introduce custom cake designs that became signature offerings.
Nicolle
Current Owner
Former employee who acquired the business in 2024, continuing the tradition of quality baked goods while maintaining the original team.
Questions
Do you make custom wedding cakes?
Yes, we create custom wedding cakes and dessert tables with various flavor combinations and design options.
What allergy-friendly options are available?
We offer gluten-free desserts and can create allergy-specific tasting boxes for guests.
Can I schedule a cake tasting?
Tastings are available monthly for $25, including cake, filling, and frosting selections.
Do you deliver and set up dessert tables?
Yes, we offer delivery and full setup services for dessert tables and event displays.
Are cookie decorating workshops available?
Monthly themed cookie decorating workshops are offered for all skill levels.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards and electronic payments for all orders and services.