Business Details
32 Years
experience
Tranquil Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island
Since 1994, J & S Reeve Cottages has provided a unique waterfront vacation experience on Long Island's North Fork. Our family-owned and operated property offers six distinct cottages nestled along Reeves Creek and the Peconic Bay, combining rustic charm with modern comforts. Each self-catering accommodation features full kitchens, screened-in porches, and direct water access for complimentary kayaking, canoeing, and paddleboarding. We maintain rigorous cleanliness standards, using alcohol-based disinfectants for all surfaces and implementing thorough linen-washing protocols.As on-site residents with decades of local knowledge, we personally guide guests to nearby wineries, farm stands, and cultural attractions while ensuring seamless connectivity with high-speed Wi-Fi. Our three-acre property balances serene natural surroundings with convenient access to major shopping centers and regional attractions like Greenport Village and the Hamptons.
Services
Waterfront Vacation Rentals
Self-Catering Cottages
Pet-Friendly Stays
Kayak Rentals
Paddle Board Access
Winery Proximity
Garden Accommodations
Extended Stay Options
Wedding Guest Housing
Local Area Guidance
Details
- Year established: 1994
Highlights and features
- We've operated waterfront cottages since 1994 with firsthand local expertise
- Direct water access with complimentary kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards
- Pet-friendly accommodations with spacious three-acre property
- Rigorous post-stay cleaning using alcohol-based disinfectants
- On-site residents providing personalized guest assistance
What people say
Tranquil living
Clean and well-maintained
Direct water access
Excellent location
Friendly owners
Services
Waterfront Vacation Rentals
Our premium waterfront cottages offer direct access to Peconic Bay's scenic waterways. Each 2-bedroom unit sleeps up to 6 guests with modern kitchens, screened-in porches, and complimentary watercrafts. Located on three acres of manicured gardens, these accommodations blend rustic charm with contemporary comforts like high-speed Wi-Fi and fully equipped kitchens.
Self-Catering Cottages
All cottages feature full-size kitchens with cooking utensils and appliances. Guests enjoy flexible meal preparation while maintaining access to nearby grocery stores and local farm stands. Each unit provides barbecue facilities and dining areas for private culinary experiences amidst tranquil natural surroundings with bay views from multiple accommodations.
Water Activity Rentals
Direct water access includes free kayak, canoe, and paddleboard rentals. Our property maintains multiple launch points along Reeves Creek and Peconic Bay. No additional fees apply for these recreational activities, which allow guests to explore local waterways and discover scenic coves at their leisure during their stay.
Pet-Friendly Stays
We welcome pets in all cottage units with no additional fees. Spacious outdoor areas include secure garden spaces and waterfront access points for pet activities. Each accommodation provides pet-friendly amenities while maintaining rigorous cleaning protocols to ensure comfort for all guests and their animal companions.
Local Area Guidance
As long-term residents, we provide personalized recommendations for nearby attractions including 40+ wineries, farm stands, and cultural sites. Guests receive detailed guidance on regional dining options, shopping centers, and transportation logistics. Our on-site presence ensures real-time assistance with itinerary planning and local event information.
People
Sandy Reeve
Co-Owner
Sandy Reeve co-owns J & S Reeve Cottages with her husband John. As on-site residents, she personally oversees guest services and maintains the property's three-acre grounds. With over 25 years of hospitality experience, she provides personalized recommendations for local attractions while ensuring cleanliness and comfort standards.
John Reeve
Co-Owner
John Reeve co-founded the business with Sandy in 1994. He manages property maintenance and watercraft operations while sharing his extensive knowledge of local history and outdoor activities. His hands-on approach ensures guests enjoy both the natural surroundings and modern comforts across the waterfront cottages.
Questions
What types of cottages are available?
We offer six cottages with 1-2 bedrooms sleeping 2-6 guests. Premier cottages face the water while Cozy Cottages offer garden views with screened-in porches.
Are pets allowed?
Yes, all cottages are pet-friendly with no additional fees. Secure outdoor areas and waterfront access points accommodate pets of all sizes.
What water activities are included?
Complimentary kayaks, canoes, and paddleboards available for guest use with direct water access from our property to Peconic Bay.
How to book stays?
Book directly through our website to avoid OTA fees. We accept reservations for nightly, weekly, monthly, and extended stays year-round.
What nearby attractions exist?
Within 30 minutes: 40+ North Fork wineries, Greenport Village shops, Hamptons beaches, and local farm stands recommended by our on-site staff.
What cleaning protocols are followed?
We use alcohol-based disinfectants for all surfaces, deep-clean kitchens and bathrooms post-stay, and wash linens in heavy cycles to ensure maximum hygiene standards.
Videos