Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Civil Litigation Attorneys in Garden City, NY
Founded in 1890, our firm has built a legacy of excellence in civil litigation, specializing in defense litigation, insurance law, automobile liability, premises liability, and labor law. Our attorneys are dedicated to delivering high-quality legal representation in all New York federal and state courts, with a focus on the five boroughs of New York City and surrounding counties. With over 130 years of combined experience, our team of partners, associates, and legal professionals is committed to achieving favorable outcomes for clients through strategic trial and appellate practice. Our attorneys possess the expertise to handle complex cases, including those involving elevation-related hazards, construction accidents, and insurance disputes. We maintain a strong track record of success at the trial level and in appellate courts, supported by a deep understanding of New York legal standards.

Our practice areas include General Litigation, Premises Liability, Labor Law, Automobile Accidents, Product Liability, and Appellate Practice. We serve clients across the New York Metropolitan Area, combining historical expertise with modern legal strategies. Our attorneys have secured defense verdicts in high-profile cases involving personal injury, medical malpractice, and commercial disputes. We prioritize client service, ensuring personalized attention and transparent communication throughout the legal process. Our recent successes include appellate victories in cases involving Labor Law 240(1) claims and defense verdicts in complex personal injury litigation.
Services
General Litigation Premises Liability Labor Law Automobile Accidents Product Liability Appellate Practice
Highlights and features
  • We have over 130 years of combined experience in civil litigation.
  • Our attorneys specialize in New York insurance defense and labor law.
  • We maintain a strong appellate practice with recent Second Department victories.
  • Our team handles complex cases involving construction accidents and personal injury.
  • We serve clients across the New York Metropolitan Area with personalized representation.
What people say
Favorable appellate decisions Successful defense verdicts Experienced legal team Strong trial record Client-focused representation
Services
General Litigation
Our general litigation practice handles complex civil disputes in New York courts, focusing on insurance defense and commercial litigation. We represent clients in trials and appeals across multiple jurisdictions, including federal and state courts. Our attorneys combine strategic thinking with courtroom experience to achieve favorable outcomes.
Premises Liability
We defend property owners and managers against liability claims involving accidents and injuries on their premises. Our attorneys have successfully handled cases related to roadway defects, construction sites, and commercial property hazards. We focus on proving lack of negligence and demonstrating compliance with safety standards.
Labor Law
Our labor law practice defends employers against claims under New York Labor Law sections 200, 240(1), and 241(6). We handle construction accident cases and workplace injury claims, emphasizing proper safety protocols and absence of elevation-related hazards in our defense strategies.
Automobile Accidents
We represent clients in automobile accident cases involving personal injury claims and insurance disputes. Our attorneys analyze accident details, challenge medical causation claims, and present evidence of pre-existing conditions when applicable. We have secured defense verdicts in complex rear-end collision cases.
Appellate Practice
Our appellate team handles complex legal appeals in civil litigation matters. We focus on overturning unfavorable lower court decisions through thorough legal analysis and strategic argumentation. Recent successes include appellate dismissals of Labor Law 240(1) claims and defense verdict affirmations in personal injury cases.
People
William J. Croutier, Jr.
Partner
Experienced trial attorney specializing in insurance defense and complex litigation with decades of courtroom experience in New York state courts.
Michael J. Pender
Partner
Skilled litigator focusing on premises liability and labor law cases with a proven track record in appellate court victories.
Richard C. Koehler
Partner
Seasoned attorney with expertise in construction accident defense and appellate practice, recently securing defense verdicts in premises liability cases.
Paul D. Lawless
Partner
Trial specialist with multiple defense verdicts in automobile accident and personal injury cases, including complex medical causation disputes.
Rebecca J. Moulton
Associate
Emerging legal professional contributing to appellate successes, including recent Second Department victories in labor law litigation matters.
Questions
What areas of law do you specialize in?
We specialize in civil litigation with focus areas including premises liability, labor law, automobile accidents, product liability, and appellate practice.
How experienced is your legal team?
Our attorneys have over 130 years of combined experience handling complex litigation cases in New York state and federal courts.
Do you handle cases outside New York City?
We represent clients throughout the New York Metropolitan Area, including surrounding counties and Long Island.
What types of defense cases do you handle?
We defend clients in insurance liability cases, construction accidents, personal injury claims, and commercial litigation matters.
Can you handle appellate cases?
Yes, we maintain a dedicated appellate practice with recent successes in the Appellate Division Second Department.