Business Details
23 Years
experience
Your Favorite Pizza Awaits at American Pie Pizzeria
Founded in 2003, American Pie Pizzeria has grown from a single location in Barnesville, GA to six thriving restaurants across Georgia. Our commitment to quality ingredients, handcrafted recipes, and a welcoming family atmosphere has made us a local favorite. We specialize in creating unique pizza experiences, from our signature butter balls to custom-built pies with over 20 toppings. With decades of combined culinary experience, our team prioritizes taste, consistency, and customer satisfaction. Our menu features specialty pizzas like the Five Meat Pie and Buffalo Chicken, alongside fresh salads, hearty subs, and decadent desserts.We operate with transparency, offering clear pricing and portion sizes to ensure value for every customer. Our family-owned business remains dedicated to community engagement and continuous improvement. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, we strive to deliver exceptional service and unforgettable flavors. As we expand, we maintain the same passion for pizza that began in our founders' childhood kitchens.
Services
Pizza
Appetizers
Salads
Subs
Pasta
Wings
Calzones
Desserts
Drinks
Family Deals
Details
- Year established: 2003
Highlights and features
- We offer handcrafted recipes developed over 20 years
- Our family-friendly atmosphere welcomes all ages
- Signature butter balls are a customer favorite
- Competitive pricing on family meal deals
- Consistently ranked as top local pizzeria since 2003
Services
Pizza
Custom-built pizzas with 20+ toppings, specialty pies like Five Meat and Buffalo Chicken, and family-sized options. Available in six sizes from personal to 24" party pies. All pizzas feature hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, and premium ingredients.
Appetizers
Signature appetizers including garlic butter-coated Butter Balls, cheese-stuffed Cheesestix, and Buffalo Chips with ranch. Portions range from small to large options perfect for sharing before meals or as standalone snacks.
Family Deals
Value-priced meal packages serving 4-6 people with combinations of large pizzas, appetizers, and drinks. Includes options like the Family Deal with giant pizza, butter balls, and soda pitchers at discounted rates.
Salads
Six salad options with house-made dressings and fresh ingredients. Features include grilled chicken upgrades, specialty combinations like the Betty Salad with bacon and veggies, and classic side salads.
Wings
Hot, mild, or BBQ sauce options for wing orders in 6, 12, or 20-piece portions. Served with ranch or blue cheese dressing for dipping, available as standalone orders or meal additions.
Questions
What are your most popular menu items?
Our signature Butter Balls and Buffalo Chicken Pizza consistently top customer favorites, along with the Five Meat Pie and family meal deals.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we cater events with pizza trays, wing platters, and custom orders for parties of all sizes. Contact your local location for details.
What pizza sizes do you offer?
We serve pizzas in six sizes: 7" Personal, 12" Small, 15" Medium, 18" Large, 24" Party Pie, and custom tray sizes for catering.
Are there gluten-free options available?
We offer gluten-sensitive pizza crusts at all locations and can prepare many menu items without gluten-containing ingredients upon request.
Do you have vegetarian pizza options?
Yes, our Veggie Pie and White Pie feature no meat, and you can customize any pizza with vegetable toppings like mushrooms, peppers, and spinach.
What are your current operating hours?
We're open Monday-Thursday 11 AM-9 PM, Friday-Saturday 11 AM-10 PM, and closed on Sundays for regular service.