Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Trusted Vacation Rentals on Cayuga Lake in Trumansburg, NY
Nestled on 4 acres of secluded Cayuga Lake frontage, The Spotted Sandpiper offers premier vacation rental experiences in the Finger Lakes region. Our property features 2 houses, 8 cottages, 2 yurts, and a beachfront bunkhouse, accommodating groups of all sizes. With 400 feet of private shoreline and amenities like fire pits, private docks, and modernized interiors, we specialize in creating memorable stays for family reunions, weddings, and retreats.

Strategically located 7 minutes from Trumansburg and 20 minutes from Ithaca, our guests enjoy both tranquility and convenient access to local attractions. Each dwelling combines comfort with rustic charm, featuring kitchens, sleeping quarters, and outdoor entertainment spaces tailored to diverse group needs.
Services
Lake House Rentals Cabin Rentals Yurt Accommodations Bunkhouse Stays Wedding Venue Rentals Family Reunion Packages Pet-Friendly Stays Seasonal Discounts
Highlights and features
  • We offer the largest private lakefront rental property in the Ithaca area
  • Our 14 unique accommodations sleep 4-23 guests with flexible configurations
  • We provide direct access to 400 feet of secluded Cayuga Lake shoreline
  • Our properties feature modern amenities including renovated interiors and kitchenettes
  • We offer proximity to major attractions like Taughannock Falls State Park
Services
Lake House Rentals
Our spacious 2,200 sq.ft. Lake House Complex sleeps 23 guests with 7 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and direct beach access. Features include private docks, grilling stations, and multi-level living spaces designed for large groups seeking immersive lakeside experiences.
Cabin Rentals
Eight uniquely named cabins ranging from 550-1,000 sq.ft. offer cozy retreats for 4-6 guests. Recently renovated units feature bamboo flooring, modern appliances, and private porches with lake views while maintaining rustic charm in a wooded setting.
Yurt Accommodations
Two Mongolian-style yurts with domed ceilings sleep 5-6 guests each. Equipped with queen/full beds, kitchenettes, and full bathrooms, these 3-season units combine traditional design with modern comforts like air conditioning and vinyl insulation.
Bunkhouse Stays
Our air-conditioned bunkhouse with 2 twin bunk sets sleeps 4 guests. Located directly on the beach, this compact unit connects to Lake House and Cottage rentals for combined group accommodations with immediate lake access.
Wedding Venue Rentals
Overlook Lodge and Lake House Complex provide scenic venues for weddings and events. With capacity for 12+ guests, these spaces feature lakefront porches, open-plan living areas, and proximity to Ithaca's top attractions for celebration hosting.
Questions
What types of accommodations are available at The Spotted Sandpiper?
We offer 2 houses, 8 cottages, 2 yurts, and a beachfront bunkhouse with sleeping capacities ranging from 4 to 23 guests.
Are pets allowed in the rental properties?
Pet-friendly options are available - please inquire about specific dwellings that accommodate pets during booking.
What lake activities are accessible to guests?
Our private beach provides swimming, fishing, and fire pit areas with complimentary use of kayaks and paddle boats.
Can we host weddings or large events at your property?
Yes, our Lake House Complex and Overlook Lodge are popular venues for weddings and events with capacity for 12+ guests.
What amenities are included in the rental units?
All accommodations include kitchens or kitchenettes, bedding, heating/AC, and outdoor seating areas with select units featuring lofts and porches.
Do you offer discounts for extended stays?
We provide discounts for weekly rentals, early bookings, and multiple unit reservations - contact us for current promotional rates.