Business Details
Your Historic Retreat in Sharon Springs, NY
We are a historic boutique hotel nestled in the heart of Sharon Springs, New York, offering guests a unique blend of timeless elegance and modern comfort. Our property features nine individually appointed guest rooms, each designed with distinct character and equipped with amenities such as Smart TVs, mini refrigerators, and complimentary WiFi. Our culinary offerings include a sumptuous, made-to-order breakfast and an on-site restaurant open Thursday through Monday evenings, with weekend brunch launching soon.As new owners with decades of experience in travel and hospitality, we are committed to preserving the hotels legacy while providing exceptional service in a location steeped in history. Our mission is to create memorable experiences for guests exploring the Leatherstocking region, surrounded by the natural beauty of the Catskills and Adirondacks.
Services
Boutique Accommodations
Gourmet Breakfast
Seasonal Restaurant
Event Hosting
Local Tours
Highlights and features
- We offer decades of hospitality experience in a historic setting.
- Our rooms combine unique design with modern amenities like Smart TVs and free WiFi.
- We provide personalized service in a prime location near major attractions.
- Our pet-friendly policy accommodates guests with pets in designated rooms.
- We guarantee a sumptuous, made-to-order breakfast included in your stay.
What people say
Wonderful stay
Charming room
Delicious breakfast
Welcoming owner
Historic charm
Services
Boutique Accommodations
Our nine individually appointed guest rooms offer a blend of historic charm and modern amenities. Each room features a private bath, Smart TV with free Hulu access, mini refrigerator, and complimentary WiFi. Designed for comfort, rooms include queen, king, or twin beds, with select ADA-compliant and pet-friendly options available.
Gourmet Breakfast
Start your day with a made-to-order breakfast featuring fresh ingredients and our signature Stagecoach Coffee blend. Served daily from 8-9 AM, the menu caters to diverse tastes while emphasizing quality and local flavors, included in your overnight stay.
Seasonal Restaurant
Our on-site restaurant offers dinner Thursday through Monday evenings, with weekend brunch launching soon. The menu highlights regional cuisine in a cozy, historic setting. Reservations are available from 5-8 PM, with the pub opening at 4 PM for casual drinks.
Event Hosting
We accommodate private events like the October 16, 2025, closure for a special gathering. Our venue combines historic ambiance with personalized service, ideal for weddings, meetings, or community celebrations in a unique setting.
Local Tours
We assist guests in exploring Sharon Springs and the Leatherstocking region. Nearby attractions include Cooperstown, the National Baseball Hall of Fame, Howe Caverns, and the New York State Route 20 Scenic Byway, all easily accessible from our location.
People
Michael Palaia
Co-Owner
Co-owner with Marco Braeutigam, bringing decades of hospitality experience to The American Hotel. Formerly lived in Philadelphia and Lake Tranquility, NJ, before discovering Sharon Springs in 2024.
Marco Braeutigam
Co-Owner
Co-owner with Michael Palaia, Marco moved from Thuringia, Germany, to Philadelphia before relocating to Sharon Springs. Combines international perspective with deep hospitality expertise.
Questions
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 3-5 PM, and check-out is by 11 AM.
Does the hotel allow pets?
Pets are allowed in Room #1 only at $25/night. They must be leashed and crated when in the guestroom.
Is breakfast included in the room rate?
Yes, a made-to-order breakfast is included daily for all guests.
What is the cancellation policy?
Cancellations made 14+ days prior receive a refund less $35 per room. Cancellations within 14 days are non-refundable unless rooms are rebooked.
Are there nearby attractions?
Yes, we’re near Cooperstown, the Catskills, Adirondacks, and the New York State Route 20 Scenic Byway. Local shops and restaurants are also accessible.
Is the hotel accessible for guests with disabilities?
Room #1 is ADA-compliant with wheelchair-accessible features.
